November 16, 2026

Personal Reflections

My favorite Christmas story of all time has to be A Christmas Carol. I love the book, its many film adaptations, and have had the pleasure of seeing it brought to life on stage by numerous theater companies. Some versions are better than others, capturing the true essence of Dickens' work and warming the coals of my heart, while others are as cold as Scrooge's office on Christmas Eve. Last weekend, my mom and I headed to the movies to see the newest film adaptation of Ebenezer starring Johnny Depp as the title character. Sitting in the movie theaters, I found myself balancing many things at once: the candy I snuck in, my high expectations, my revere for Dickens work, and an open mind. This is what I left the theater with:

This film adaptation had a lot going for it, particularly in the way it contrasted the economic classes, explored the emotional arcs of its many characters, and tied up some of the loose ends left by Dickens' original story. Personally, I think Rupert Grint played the best Bob Cratchit I've seen to date, while Sam Claflin made an equally wonderful Fred. The one thing I wasn't particularly fond of during my first viewing was just how frightening the ghosts were (I’m looking at you Ghost of Christmas Past). Seriously, I kept tucking myself into my mom like a five-year-old! After the film, my mom and I came to a realization together: A Christmas Carol was always meant to be a ghost story, and Scrooge was always meant to be scared. Perhaps, for the first time, that notion truly felt plausible to me.

Until attending Theater Artists Olympia's Yuletide Spirits event last year, I hadn't fully appreciated just how strangely delightful the British Christmas ghost story tradition could be. [Another one of my favorite Christmas ghost stories is The Cremation of Sam McGee by Robert W. Service, especially when read by Johnny Cash. Give it a listen here!]

With all of this tumbling around in my brain, I've come to a rather nuanced conclusion: each adaptation of A Christmas Carol adds something new or reveals something different about Dickens' original story and our understanding of it. Even the beloved children's adaptations, like Mickey's Christmas Carol and The Muppet Christmas Carol, remain treasured by the children in all of us because their music, imaginative character interpretations, or the little details that bring the story to life in these versions have a way of speaking straight to our hearts.

This isn't unique to A Christmas Carol. So many beloved stories have found new life through film, stage productions, music, and literary adaptations. Take Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, for example. It has countless adaptations including off the wall retellings like Bridget Jones's Diary, The Shop Around the Corner, and You've Got Mail.

This is why we need the arts! Can you imagine a world without all of these incredible retellings? We are such a fortunate audience to experience the creative works of artistic geniuses through so many different mediums and interpretations. How incredible is it that stories can become immortal, not simply because they continue to be retold, but because each new generation breathes fresh life, new perspectives, and new meaning into them? This really is a privilege, and an important one. We need to keep revisiting these classic stories, finding new ways to experience them, and remembering the lessons they have to teach us. Especially now, in a world increasingly consumed by technological advancement and digital distractions, that is making us lose sight of our humanity.

Now, there is one other element of this conversation that deserves some attention: When does it go too far? In other words, when do we reach a point where there are simply too many retellings and new versions of the same story? Is it a copout to say that it's all in the eye of the beholder? Honestly, I think it might be, but it doesn’t make it less true. Take the new You've Got Mail reboot reportedly in the works in Hollywood. Some people might be absolutely thrilled by the prospect, but personally, the news gives me heartburn (Nora Ephron pun not originally intended... Look, Mom, I'm clever! Yay!).

Heartburn aside, who am I really to complain? If a new adaptation isn't hurting anyone, what's wrong with it? Shouldn't I be happy that another generation might discover and fall in love with this incredible story? How terribly self centered is it to think that just because I don’t like the idea of something, everyone else should agree with me. Again, the beauty of the arts is that there is something for everyone.

Look at me now! I'm trying to balance even more things in my hands. Perhaps this is sometimes what life is like when you're living in the audience. You know what? I really like it.

Thank you all for continuing to join me on this journey.

Now, quick! Name your favorite A Christmas Carol film adaptations! Mine include Mickey's Christmas Carol, The Muppet Christmas Carol, George C. Scott's A Christmas Carol (an absolute classic!), and The Man Who Invented Christmas. I'm still undecided about whether Ebenezer deserves a spot on that list. Perhaps I'll need another viewing to make up my mind!

Hope for the Holidays

Do you have a wonderful story to share from the arts this year? Whether you are an artist or audience member, I invite you to share your story with me for an article I want to publish the week of Christmas in my JOLT Column. Is this kind of like a festive Chicken Noodle Soup? Yes, it admittedly is, but I think these lovely local stories would be very meaningful for everyone this holiday season, especially after this chaotic year.

I will be accepting stories until December 15th.

Click here to share your story.

This Week in the Arts

I will be publishing three pieces in my JOLT Column including:

  • Review: Timberline High School’s ‘Come From Away’

  • Review: Harlequin Productions ‘Harlequin Miscast’

  • Seasonal Shows at South Puget Sound Community College

I will be publishing these articles under Rachel’s Choice:

  • Maybe something, maybe not something. We’ll see what happens.

To read my articles as they come out, I invite you to subscribe to The JOLT News and follow me on Instagram and Facebook, then invite a friend to do the same! :)

If you read a story that inspires you, I invite you to share it with others and help spread the word about the incredible things happening in the Thurston County Arts Community.

Other Fun Things This Week

  • For the Record: ‘Mame’ Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Events with Rachel

Night of Nostalgia ~ Bygone Radio Shows w/The Dare to Love Project: November 19th @ 6:00pm. Come listen to old radio shows curated by yours truly and enjoy reminiscing with friends and community. Word searches, fidgets, and coloring available during listening session. More event information can be found here.

Email me for address.

…


If you would like to add a tip to my “tip jar”, I invite you to click below. All tips are greatly appreciated!

Like this newsletter? Subscribe here.

Next
Next

November 9, 2026