Olympia Symphony Orchestra to play Gershwin’s ‘Rhapsody in Blue’

Published September 21, 2026

What better day to write about a piece that captures the hustle and bustle of an always-moving life than a Monday, when the chaos feels like it’s at its highest? George Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue may more specifically conjure images of cities like New York, but Gershwin wrote the piece for a concert intended to celebrate the American spirit. Perhaps busyness is simply part of our collective DNA?

Whenever I think of American patriotic music, it tends to have a certain quality that I associate more with the South—or Main Street, U.S.A., at Disneyland—than anything else. Gershwin, as he did throughout his life, pushed the envelope, challenging us to consider what our country could sound like when we embrace all of its influences. Classical music and jazz were, in some ways, like Romeo and Juliet: a love affair written in the stars, yet complicated by prejudice and convention.

Rhapsody in Blue was countercultural in its time because of that, and because it captured the grit, energy, and unpredictability of real life. Audiences followed Gershwin's lead back then and embraced it because it felt authentic—not only to the world around them, but to how they experienced American life. Besides, it’s really incredible music; how could they possibly not love it? 102 years later, audiences still resonate with this piece.

When talking about Rhapsody in Blue, Gershwin commented, "The rhapsody, as you see, began as a purpose, not a plan. I tried to conceive the composition as a whole. I heard it as a sort of musical kaleidoscope of America – of our vast melting-pot, of our unduplicated national pep, of our blues, our metropolitan madness.”

I think a life lived through a kaleidoscope is the richest kind of life. It invites us to look into the light and explore every angle, revealing something new and beautiful to those who are open-minded enough to see it.

Lucky for us, we have a Symphony inviting us to do just that for an entire season. I look forward to embarking on this journey together with out Olympia Symphony Orchestra (OSO) at the Lift season premiere. On the day of the concert, keep an eye on the @olysymphony instagram account, I’m taking it over again this concert!

This train leaves October 11 at 3 p.m. Hurry and get your ticket before the seats sell out!

Until then, I invite you to grab your hot beverage of choice and join me for a conversation about the history of George Gershwin and his Rhapsody in Blue.

NOTE: This piece would not have been possible without the encouragement and education I received from OSO’s Communications Manager, Mando Surita III. I imagine I will never fully know—or even begin to grasp—everything they understand about music history, but the conversation we had continues to give me a great deal to think about.

Let me introduce you to George

George—or shall I say, George Gershwin—was born in Brooklyn, New York, on September 26, 1898. A first-generation American born to Russian-Jewish immigrants, George and his brother Ira would go on to make Broadway history. Wait, I shouldn’t get ahead of myself. Along the way, George showed musical promise and chose to pursue a life in the arts, dropping out of high school at age 15. One of his first jobs included working as a song plugger, essentially a musician who would play songs for hours in order to persuade people to buy the sheet music. He also made piano rolls under a pseudonym. He composed music of his own, but it wasn’t until Broadway that the brothers made a real name for themselves! I invite you to explore their show, film, concert, and song catalogs…it is quite impressive! In fact, many of my personal favorites can be found within their canon!

When I hear that a handsome man of the early 20th century chose never to marry, my first assumption is that he was gay. Perhaps George Gershwin was part of the LGBTQ+ community, but no definitive evidence establishes that. The rumors surrounding his personal life tend to focus instead on his relationships with women, including reports of an affair with Paulette Goddard, one of Charlie Chaplin’s wives, as discussed by Turner Classic Movies here.

We’ll talk about his midlife—aka Rhapsody in Blue—in just a moment, but OSO will also be featuring “Catfish Row” from Porgy and Bess in their concert. Gershwin co-wrote the opera with his brother, Ira, and DuBose Heyward, and it premiered in 1935, just two years before Gershwin’s death. In 1937, Gershwin experienced “increasingly severe headaches and dizzy spells. He collapsed into a coma caused by a brain tumor on July 9 and died on July 11, 1937, at just 38 years old,” according to the Kennedy Center here.

Throughout his life, Gershwin faced discrimination in a number of ways: as the son of Russian immigrants, as a Jewish man, and as someone who thought beyond the boundaries of both the Classical and Jazz worlds. All of those things together—imagine with me for a moment—the limitations he may have faced.

His legacy has become complicated in another way, as people continue to debate whether Rhapsody in Blue, or for that matter, Porgy and Bess, are works of cultural appropriation. More on that in just a moment.

Everything I have learned about Gershwin suggests that he was like a shooting star: gone far too soon, but shining ever so brightly while he was in our orbit. An extraordinary creative force, Gershwin left behind music that remains immortal and timeless because it speaks to both the real and romantic parts of being alive. I personally can’t wait to thank him for it in heaven.

Rhapsody in Blue

Last week, I printed about 12 online articles and highlighted them like crazy. Many historical articles share the same basic facts, but some invite you to look between the lines—and that’s where things get really interesting.

Every article out there will tell you that bandleader Paul Whiteman asked Gershwin to write something for his concert, An Experiment in Modern Music, at Aeolian Hall in New York City. The goal was to show audiences that jazz was a worthy, sophisticated art form with tremendous potential. Gershwin initially said no, yet a few months later, he reportedly learned that he was composing a piece for the concert—which was only about a month away. The problem? He hadn’t agreed to it or written it yet and was busy working on Sweet Little Devil for Broadway.

The exact writing timeline remains a little fuzzy. Some accounts suggest Gershwin wrote much of the piece in roughly 10 days. Either way, he somehow had Rhapsody in Blue ready for the concert in an astonishing 30 days. He aimed to marry elements of classical music and jazz while showcasing what he saw as America's full beauty, energy, and possibilities.

“During that short month, Gershwin found inspiration for the new piece on a train ride from New York to Boston: ‘It was on the train, with its steely rhythms, its rattlety-bang that is often so stimulating to a composer. . . . And there I suddenly heard—and even saw on paper—the complete construction of the Rhapsody, from beginning to end. . . . I heard it as a sort of musical kaleidoscope of America—of our vast melting pot, of our unduplicated national pep, of our metropolitan madness. By the time I reached Boston I had a definite plot of the piece.’” (RI Phil).

Ira made two key suggestions: change the name from American Rhapsody to Rhapsody in Blue, and incorporate a contrast between lively syncopation and a more lyrical, romantic theme.

The concert sold out, and by the time it was Rhapsody’s turn to shine, the audience had already sat through more than two hours of music. Famous figures including Sergei Rachmaninoff and Igor Stravinsky were reportedly in attendance. Then Rhapsody in Blue happened—and suddenly, the room was revived, and the love story lives on. The piece went on to inspire fellow composers, musicians, and audiences for generations. That legacy includes Fantasia 2000, whose performance is what made me fall in love with this piece, jazz, and classical music at a very young age.

There is more to this story than meets the eye, and my own conclusions keep changing each day as I think about it. I want you to read these pieces of evidence—or, rather, these “news clippings”—for yourself so you can draw your own conclusions.

Regardless of where you stand on the cultural appropriation question, one thing I can confidently say is that everyone in these conversations believes Gershwin's intentions were good.

News Clippings to Piece the Story Together

NPR:

  • "My idea for the concert,’ Whiteman wrote in his autobiography, ‘was to show these skeptical people the advance which had been made in popular music from the day of the discordant early jazz to the melodious form of the present.’ Judging from that, and articles such as one in a 1921 edition of Ladies' Home Journal whose headline read ‘Does Jazz Put the Sin in Syncopation?’ one might wonder whether Whiteman was trying to whitewash the perceived lowbrow origins of jazz for the elites comfortably seated in their temple of classical music.”

  • "Gershwin is well aware of what he's doing, and he really doesn't give a damn what people think," says Joseph Horowitz, author of Classical Music in America: A History of its Rise and Fall. "He wanted to bridge musical worlds that were separate."

  • “‘I think that a lot of the writing in Rhapsody in Blue definitely is not stuff that Gershwin learned in his piano lessons as a young boy,’ says pianist Lara Downes, who has played the Rhapsody many times and is touring a new version of it. Sitting at her own piano to demonstrate, Downes says Gershwin picked up a lot from the stride piano giants, some of whom were his friends, such as James P. Johnson, Willie "The Lion" Smith and Luckey Roberts, who claimed he gave Gershwin lessons. ‘It's this very athletic kind of playing,’ she says. And you can hear it through much of the Rhapsody.

    But Downes hears more than just jazz in Gershwin's piece — she hears politics. ‘Just three months after Rhapsody in Blue was performed, the Johnson-Reed Act was passed,’ she points out. ‘Incredibly xenophobic, anti-immigrant legislation that essentially shut down Ellis Island, completely stopped immigration from Asia, drastically cut back immigration from southern and Eastern Europe.’

    Gershwin himself was a second-generation Russian immigrant, who told biographer Isaac Goldberg he thought of his Rhapsody as ‘a musical kaleidoscope of America.’ You can hear sounds of Tin Pan Alley, where as a teenager he worked as a song promoter; there are whiffs of Yiddish theatre, Spanish music, the hurdy-gurdies of the Lower East Side and, of course, jazz.

    ‘I don't hear Rhapsody in Blue anymore as just a piece of entertainment,’ Downes adds. ‘I think it's a little bit of an act of rebellion, or at the very least, it's a statement about what America should be and what that sounds like.’”

Strings Magazine

  • “Whiteman made it a point to include luminaries from the classical world among the overflow audience that braved the bitter winter weather: Jascha Heifetz, Igor Stravinsky, Mary Garden, and Leopold Stokowski among them. He later described the audience as a motley mix of ‘vaudevillians, concert managers come to have a look at the novelty, Tin Pan Alleyites, composers, symphony and opera stars, flappers, cake-eaters, all mixed up higgledy-piggledy.’” [NOTE: I also read somewhere, a place I can no longer find, that fancy ladies with white gloves and pearls were in the audience, and were blown away by the cultural contrast shown in Gershwin’s piece].

  • “Leonard Bernstein, a fervent admirer of Gershwin, also had a complicated relationship with his predecessor and dismissed Rhapsody in Blue in a famous diatribe as ‘not a composition at all’ but ‘a string of separate paragraphs stuck together—with a thin paste of flour and water.’ Bernstein himself, of course, would face similar charges in his attempts to move between what were perceived as the inherently separate musical spheres of classical, Broadway, and jazz.”

The New York Times, whose writers disagree and contradict each other at every given opportunity. Observe Ethan Iverson, John McWhorter, and Stanley Crouch.

  • Iverson: claimed that Rhapsody in Blue was “corny and Caucasian,” a “cheesecake that has clogged the arteries of American Music.” Also, he claims that it is not jazzy enough and fails because it doesn’t “jam.”

  • McWhorter: “Of course, it is important to acknowledge that the rhapsody was, by our modern standards, cultural appropriation. Althought he did it with sincere artistic intent, Gershwin adopted Black musical forms and as a result gained the fame and fortune that racism at the time made impossible for actual Black American Composers.”

  • Crouch: “Those who praise Gershwin see him as a number of things: a composer whose work epitomized the Golden Era of popular songwriting, a true example of the rags-to-riches story, a genius from the streets who pulled telling strands of American sound together and whose innovations earned him a position in the pantheon.

    All of that is absolutely true. Gershwin was great. He did have a snap. He was a first-class popular melodist. His sound, part Negro and part everything else that was going on when he came to power, is one of the most important distillations of lyric and rhythmic American feeling to arrive in the first half of the 20th century. He was one of the musical poets of modern life. We cannot accurately think of urban American existence with any accuracy and leave him out […] The brother had soul.

    […] In particular, however, the exchanges or the homemade academies of jam sessions and rent parties and private lessons from men like James P. Johnson resulted in an extraordinary irony: with the exception of Duke Ellington, Gershwin went on to become a finer songwriter than any of the Negroes who were his contemporaries or who influenced him.

    That is where we get the rub and where the attacks on Gershwin for ‘stealing’ from Negroes falls flat on its lewdy duty. Given his talent, why is Gershwin also paddled so often for being something less than he actually was? Primarily because Gershwin was Jewish, and there is an extremely complicated history fundamental to the tale of Negroes and Jews in show business. It is a story of alliance, animosity, success, failure, exploitation transcending friendships and ongoing shifts of attitude and economic position.

    Show business was an open frontier for Jewish immigrants who -- often battling one another every step of the way -- rose to higher and higher positions as entrepreneurs, performers, agents, critics and so on… Complaints steam up from the fact that Jewish journeymen, in and out of blackface, were able to make use of Negro culture while benefiting from a support system capable of neutralizing the religious status of a minority in favor of its acceptably white skin. Jewish or not, white skin or not, George Gershwin was nobody's journeyman. To go a little deeper, there is another irony when the subject of ‘stealing’ comes around to Gershwin.

    That irony is found in the work of all the jazz musicians who have used his songs as jumping off points for classic improvisations, either on his themes or on the chord sequences he devised. The uncopyrightable chords of ‘I Got Rhythm,’ by the way, have been used by so many jazz musicians that we have no idea how much larger the Gershwin fortune would be if his estate could lay claim to every use of that harmonic material. So one could argue that black musicians have done much more profitable, literal stealing from Gershwin than he did from them, which, in his case, amounts to nothing more than inspired borrowing.”

List of Resources:

Previous
Previous

Why We Must Vote

Next
Next

Oly Pages ‘Writing Mindfully’ prompt responses